Using Artificial Intelligence (AI) in a tribunal case

Learn about the appropriate use of artificial intelligence (AI) in Tribunals Ontario hearings.

Get legal help for inquiries and applications related to Tribunals Ontario from participating legal clinics, referral services and resources.


Using Artificial Intelligence (AI) for Tribunal Proceedings

If you plan to use Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools, including AI chatbots, to research or help prepare for a case before one of our tribunals, read the information below carefully.

You should also review Tribunals Ontario’s Practice Direction on the Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Tribunal Proceedings .

Tribunals Ontario is aware that some parties, representatives, witnesses, and legal professionals use AI tools to help with research or to prepare documents for tribunal proceedings.

While AI can be useful, it should be used with care.

Understanding AI

AI refers to computer systems that can perform tasks that normally require human thinking and reasoning.

Generative artificial intelligence (Gen AI) is a type of AI that creates content in response to instructions, or prompts. Gen AI can create text, images, video, and audio.

Examples of Gen AI tools include Microsoft Copilot, ChatGPT, Google Gemini, and Claude.

Gen AI tools are not search engines. They may not search trusted or authoritative sources for information. Instead, they generate responses based on the information they were trained on and the prompts they receive. This means AI-generated content can contain mistakes even when it appears accurate.

Using AI to Help Prepare Your Case

You may use AI to help prepare for your case. However, you are responsible for reviewing and verifying everything the AI tool creates.

Any information you submit to the tribunal must be accurate, complete, relevant, and appropriate for your case, even if AI helped prepare it.

Always check AI-generated information against trusted sources to make sure it is accurate and reliable. This helps support fair and reliable tribunal proceedings.

Risks of Using AI

AI can be helpful, but it is not a substitute for legal advice, professional representation, or independent research.

When using AI, be aware of the following risks:

  • AI may create cases, laws, quotations, or legal sources that do not exist. These errors are sometimes called “hallucinations.”
  • AI may provide incorrect or misleading information about the law, tribunal procedures, or legal principles.
  • AI tools are designed to be helpful and agreeable, which means they may not provide an accurate analysis of your case.
  • AI-generated documents may be too long, repetitive, or include information that is not relevant to the issues in dispute. This can make it difficult for the tribunal to understand what you are trying to tell them.
  • AI may not follow tribunal requirements, such as page limits, filing rules, or directions given by an adjudicator.
  • AI generates content using information from many sources, including websites, social media, and news articles. As a result, it may present opinions, assumptions, or incorrect information as facts.
  • Some AI tools store information entered by users. As a result, private or confidential information could become available to others.
  • The tribunal may give less weight to evidence or submissions that contain inaccurate, misleading, unsupported, or fabricated information.

Reviewing Information Created with AI

Before filing a document that was prepared, reviewed, or edited using AI, make sure that:

  • All facts are accurate.
  • All names, dates, and references are correct.
  • Any legislation, cases, policies, tribunal rules, or other authorities cited exist, are relevant, and support your position.
  • Any case law has been verified using trusted sources, such as court and tribunal websites or CanLII.
  • Any tribunal information has been verified using official tribunal websites.
  • The document accurately reflects your position, instructions, and evidence, where applicable.
  • The information is current and applies to your case.

If you discover an error after filing a document, contact the tribunal as soon as possible.

Use of AI by Tribunal Members

Tribunal decisions are made by people, not AI.

Tribunal members hear cases and make decisions based on the evidence and submissions provided by the parties. They do not use AI to analyze evidence or write decisions.

Tribunal members remain fully responsible and accountable for their decisions.

Key Takeaway

Tribunals Ontario does not prohibit the use of AI tools to help prepare documents.

However, parties and representatives remain fully responsible for ensuring that any document filed with the tribunal is accurate, complete, and appropriate. Information created by AI should always be carefully reviewed and verified by a person before it is submitted to the tribunal.